http://commissarybbq.com/
I went to lunch yesterday at the Germantown Commissary. This was my first visit here even though I’ve wanted to go for several years now. I just don’t eat out for BBQ too often considering the amount I cook at home. I was in the mood yesterday and thought an adventure to Germantown would be fun and different from the norm. I was also looking forward to trying their hot BBQ sauce seeing how I have never had that before either. Lots of people love this BBQ joint so I was excited to check it out.
I heard that they can fill up quick for lunch so I got there around 11:30. I was instantly greeted at the door and was seated in an empty dining area around the counter. Some people were following me in so I quickly realized that my timing was perfect. I was then waited on by a very friendly waitress who took my order promptly. I decided early on that I would try their well-known BBQ nachos and a jumbo pulled pork sandwich. One of each would have been efficient for lunch but my quest was for the experience, not my hunger. The meal was brought out within 5 minutes and I saw that I was in for a large BBQ encounter.
I took note of the BBQ sauces on the table as well as their rub. I put some hot BBQ sauce, a few sprinkles of rub and a cup of jalapenos on the pile of chips and BBQ. I got busy with the nachos and was down 3 napkins before taking a break. As I looked around the room at all of the awesome décor of nostalgia and sports memorabilia, it dawned on me that the pork had little flavor. The sauce wasn’t really much better as they did not complement each other very well. The pork was tender, pink and plentiful but it did not have much of a smoke flavor at all. The sauce was very bland and not even remotely spicy. I found it to be missing something and lacking depth that you normally get with a BBQ sauce. It wasn’t very sweet or smokey, which is normally how Memphis BBQ sauce is made. I did like the rub, however, which was loaded with brown sugar and spices. I then ate my sandwich that was also missing all the flavors of great BBQ. Sadly, I paid my bill then proceeded back to work.
I realize that the Germantown Commissary is a local favorite in this great BBQ city and that’s fantastic. I love seeing local establishments become huge success stories where even famous people visit for the experiences of great, Memphis BBQ. This place just wasn’t for me. Maybe I am a BBQ snob but compared to what can be done with smoked swine elsewhere, the Germantown Commissary doesn’t live up to the hype, IMO.




